Chargeback reason code response examples
A chargeback is not decided on who is right. It is decided on whether the file you submit answers the specific reason code the issuer cited. Four codes account for most seller losses. Each needs a different exhibit set, and submitting the wrong set is the most common reason a valid case is lost.
The four codes that cost sellers the most
| Code | What the issuer claims | What actually wins it |
|---|---|---|
| Visa 10.4 Other fraud, card-absent | The cardholder never authorized this payment. | 3-D Secure result, AVS/CVV match, device and IP fingerprint, delivery to billing address, repeat purchase on the same card. |
| Visa 13.1 Not received | Paid, nothing delivered. | Carrier tracking with delivery scan, proof of delivery, signature, shipping address matched to the order record. |
| Visa 13.3 Not as described | Received, but materially different from the listing. | Listing snapshot at time of sale, specification and size match, photos of the shipped unit, stated return policy. |
| MC 4837 No authorization | Cardholder does not recognize the charge. | Compelling evidence: authentication result plus two or more independent matching data points. |
Diagnostic first: work out what the dispute is costing you before you spend an hour on the rebuttal. A $32 dispute and a $320 dispute justify different amounts of work.
The structure that gets accepted
- One PDF, not twelve attachments. Reviewers lose loose files. Merge everything in exhibit order.
- Page one is a cover letter. Reason code, one-sentence claim, exhibit index with each item numbered and described.
- Every exhibit answers the code, nothing else. A 10.4 file does not need your return policy. Extra material reads as padding.
- Deadline before quality. Your acquirer sets the window and it is usually shorter than sellers assume — assume seven days from the notice until your provider confirms otherwise in writing.
Cover letter skeleton (copy, then fill)
Re: Chargeback [case number] — [reason code] — order [order id] — [amount]
We are representing this transaction. The charge was authorized by the cardholder and [delivered as described / delivered to the billing address] on [date].
Exhibit 1 — Gateway transaction detail, showing AVS [result] and CVV [result].
Exhibit 2 — [3-D Secure authentication result / device fingerprint and IP log].
Exhibit 3 — Carrier tracking [number], delivery scan [date, time, location].
Exhibit 4 — Order record showing the shipping address matches the billing address on file.
Exhibit 5 — [Prior order history on this card / customer correspondence].
Requested outcome: reversal of the chargeback. Contact: [name, email].
The exhibit list is the part sellers get wrong. Each line must be a document you can actually produce, numbered in the order the reviewer will want to read it.
What to do in the first hour
- Export the gateway transaction record — not a dashboard screenshot, the full detail page with AVS, CVV and IP.
- Save the carrier tracking page as PDF, not a link. Links expire and reviewers do not click them.
- Write the cover letter before you gather the rest. It tells you which exhibits are missing.
- Do not argue with the buyer in the dispute portal. Only evidence is read.