Why does my free shipping threshold stop working during a sale?
The threshold is evaluated against a subtotal, and a discount changes which subtotal. Whether it applies before or after the discount decides whether the threshold is met.
Why the numbers break
3 patterns, and the order they usually arrive in.
- Some configurations evaluate the threshold on the pre-discount subtotal, others on the post-discount subtotal. A sale flips which one matters.
- Combined discounts can push the post-discount subtotal below the threshold, so the customer sees shipping reappear at checkout.
- Cart-level and checkout-level evaluation can differ, so the threshold appears satisfied in the cart and unsatisfied at payment.
Fix it in this order
5 steps, in the order they depend on each other.
- Determine which subtotal your threshold uses: pre-discount or post-discount. This is a configuration fact, not a guess — test it.
- Run a test order with a discount applied and watch the shipping line: at cart, at address entry, and at payment. Note where it changes.
- Decide deliberately which subtotal should govern a sale, then set it that way instead of leaving the default.
- If the intent is 'sales do not affect free shipping', evaluate on the pre-discount subtotal.
- Re-test at the exact threshold boundary and one currency unit below it — that is where the behaviour shows.
Confirm the fix
3 checks, each with a clear pass or fail.
- You can state which subtotal your threshold uses, and prove it with a test order.
- A discounted order at the boundary behaves the way you intended.
- The shipping line does not change between cart and payment for the same order.
The packaged version
the shipping-threshold and discount interaction checks behind this page are packaged as Cross-Border Automation Pack. No API key and no telemetry — it runs on Python's standard library, locally. Inside are 10 importable workflow files; the bundled self-test passes 10 of 10. One-time $37.05.
Quick answers
The 3 questions below cover the usual follow-ups.
Is this a bug?
No. It is a configuration choice you inherited. The default is one of the two options, and it may not be the one you want.
Why does it only happen during sales?
Because outside a sale the pre- and post-discount subtotals are the same, so the difference is invisible.
Can I have different rules per market?
Often yes, which is how a rule that works domestically surprises you internationally.
956231 Studio's rule-based checks and configuration behaviour; not legal advice. Updated 2026-10-23.