PayPal Approved but No Order Created: Where the Handoff Dies
This is the most expensive failure mode in WooCommerce. PayPal takes the money, WooCommerce never writes the order, and the customer has a receipt for something that does not exist in your store.
Does this match what you see?
PayPal shows the payment as completed
WooCommerce order list has no matching order
Customer has a PayPal receipt, you have no order
Stock is not reduced
Refund has to be issued manually
3-minute check, no changes to your live store
1
Read the Network sequenceA healthy flow is: save form, create order, approve order, then ?wc-ajax=checkout, then capture. Note the exact last successful call.
2
Confirm the webhook arrivedA verified CHECKOUT.ORDER.APPROVED webhook with no capture request means the frontend abandoned the flow.
3
Check whether the gateway was silently disabledMany merchants disable PayPal as an emergency stop and forget. Verify the gateway is actually enabled.
The five places it breaks
BREAK 1
Frontend stops after approve
Approve returns 200, then nothing. No capture, no order. The customer is charged into a void. This is a plugin handoff bug, not a PayPal setting.
BREAK 2
Webhook received, capture never sent
Server side accepted the event but the capture call is missing or timing out. Compare webhook timestamp with the missing capture.
BREAK 3
Token creation warnings in the log
Repeated Could not create token warnings mean the credentials are fine but something upstream is failing. Read the gateway log, not the WooCommerce status page.