A working diagnosis of this problem and the sequence that actually resolves it, written from the operational side rather than the marketing side.
Reported context: Ah yes, we're still entirely built on Stripe, so all your chargeback management, tax handling, subscriptions and payments are still handled by them! We are not a Stripe replacement. When our users integrate Autumn, they don't need to handle the state syncing or any Stripe events, as we do all of that for them. Eg, one of your users, John, subscribes to a Pro tier. We'll listen to that event from Stripe
What is actually going on
Most chargebacks are lost on evidence quality, not on merit. Generic invoices and screenshots fail the card network's representment requirements.
Dispute windows are short and network-specific. Evidence assembled after the deadline is worthless regardless of how strong it is.
The sequence that works
Identify the exact reason code. Each code has a different evidence requirement; a mismatched response is auto-lost.
Assemble a standard evidence packet: order confirmation with IP and timestamp, delivery proof with tracking, customer communication log, refund policy shown at checkout, and device fingerprint.
File representment inside the network window and reference the specific evidence elements against the reason code.
For subscription products, add a pre-debit notification at least seven days before renewal and retain delivery logs.
Track dispute rate by product and acquisition channel. A rising rate in one channel usually indicates misleading ad creative upstream.
Where people lose time
Refunding the disputed amount while still filing representment — this often forfeits the case.
Copying a generic response template across reason codes. Networks reject mismatched evidence outright.
Verify before you trust it
Run the checks above against your own data instead of adopting them at face value. The failure modes are specific enough that a single afternoon of measurement will either confirm this diagnosis or rule it out — both outcomes are useful, and guessing is not.
Shopify Cart Recovery Kit
A ready-to-use package for exactly this workflow — $29, delivered immediately.
Sold via Gumroad, which acts as merchant of record and handles payment and applicable taxes. All sales are final; see the return policy before purchase.