Cameras and secret trackers reveal where Amazon returns end up
A working diagnosis of this problem and the sequence that actually resolves it, written from the operational side rather than the marketing side.
Reported context: Anecdotally, Canada & US Amazon used to be like you described when they first started becoming the "everything" store but things have really declined lately. 6 or 7 years ago there was a much higher proportion of items actually sold by Amazon. Now it's a morass of third-party sellers with inaccurate listings to the point that even just finding an item is quite a choice. I recently gave up trying to
What is actually going on
Fee structure changes are the most common root cause. Referral fees, FBA fulfilment fees and storage surcharges are recalculated on different schedules, so a listing that was profitable last quarter silently drifts negative.
Listing indexation failures usually trace back to backend search terms exceeding the byte limit, duplicate keyword stuffing, or a suppressed buy box caused by price or availability signals.
The sequence that works
Export the last 12 months of settlement reports and rebuild unit economics per SKU: referral fee, FBA fee, inbound freight, storage, returns, ad spend.
Rank SKUs by contribution margin after ads, not by revenue. Any SKU below 15% margin is a candidate for repricing or discontinuation.
Audit backend search terms byte by byte. Remove duplicates already present in the title, and remove competitor brand names that trigger suppression.
Rebuild reorder points from actual receiving dates over the last 90 days, not from supplier promises.
Set a weekly buy box health check: price versus the lowest competing offer, stock cover in days, and suppression alerts.
Where people lose time
Optimising for keyword rank before fixing unit economics. Traffic to a negative-margin SKU accelerates losses.
Treating advertised ACOS as the only efficiency metric while ignoring organic rank decay after ads stop.
Verify before you trust it
Run the checks above against your own data instead of adopting them at face value. The failure modes are specific enough that a single afternoon of measurement will either confirm this diagnosis or rule it out — both outcomes are useful, and guessing is not.
Amazon Search Terms Playbook
A ready-to-use package for exactly this workflow — $27.55, delivered immediately.
Sold via Gumroad, which acts as merchant of record and handles payment and applicable taxes. All sales are final; see the return policy before purchase.